IMPACT CASE STUDY

Fighting fatbergs – avoiding sewer blockages

  • 23 January 2023
  • Associate Professor Tom Curran
  • Academic, Economic, Educational, Environmental, Political, Social, Technological


Summary

Fatbergs are a global issue. They form in sewers when people put fat, oils and grease down the sink, and flush products like nappies and wet wipes down the toilet. Every year, water utilities spend many millions unblocking sewers. Fatbergs also cause flooding, traffic diversions, and harm to wildlife. Dr Curran’s research has examined how we can better deal with them. As well as contributing to a UK policy steering group, and working on new technologies to tackle fatbergs, he has conducted a wide range of outreach activities – including interviews in the international media, a stand-up comedy routine, and an appearance as a comic book character – helping to raise awareness of the issue and avoid harmful and expensive sewer blockages.

Research description

Fatbergs form in sewers when households and restaurants put fats, oils and grease (FOG) into the dishwasher or down the sink, and flush products like nappies and wet wipes down the toilet. While this is a global issue, the annual cost of sewer blockages and fatberg removal in the UK alone is up to £200 million. This does not include the cost and nuisance associated with the resulting overflows, flooding of properties, traffic diversions, environmental damage, and fish kills. Four in every 10 Irish people have admitted to pouring FOG down the sink. In 2021, Irish Water responded to approximately 10,000 blockages along the wastewater network, which were leading to sewer overflows.

Despite the detrimental effects of fatbergs, there is no consistent international approach to FOG waste management. However, some successful FOG management programmes have been established in specific locations, such as in Dublin city and in Scandinavian countries.

Dr Curran’s research reviewed existing approaches to managing these fats, oils and grease. Tackling FOG and combatting the impact of fatbergs requires an understanding of three things: the various factors that cause FOG to build up in sewers; tactics to raise awareness and change behaviours; and ways in which FOG waste might be repurposed (like as a source for bioenergy or biomaterials).

The research, published in a highly cited review paper, found that the most common approach internationally is to prevent FOG from entering sewers in the first place, often through simple awareness campaigns. Despite its potential, diverted FOG is rarely used for bioenergy or biomaterials.

Dr Curran’s work highlights the importance of managing all facets of the FOG waste lifecycle in order to prevent and mitigate the extensive environmental and financial damage caused by fatbergs. This will require new processes and techniques to be developed, ensuring the future evolution of FOG waste management helps us create sustainable urban environments.

Research team and collaborators

  • Associate Professor Tom Curran (Project leader)
  • Thomas Wallace (former UCD research student, Senior Environmental Inspector, Noonan Services Group)
  • David Gibbons (UCD research student, Operations Director of Evolution Environmental Services Ltd.)
  • Michael O’Dwyer (industry partner; co-founder and CEO of SwiftComply; winner of multiple business awards; funder of research project and fatberg comics)
  • Dublin City Council
  • Irish Water

 

Funding

The research started in 2014. The work was funded by two employment-based Irish Research Council Postgraduate Scholarships (David Gibbons and Thomas Wallace) in conjunction with Evolution Environmental Services and Noonan Group; and a 2017-18 Fulbright TechImpact Award (Tom Curran).


Research impact


Social and educational impact

Dr Curran has a significant portfolio of outreach work, raising awareness of fatbergs and how people can help tackle them. For example, he explains how to cook food and clean dishes in an environmentally friendly way, and the importance of only flushing the 3 Ps down the toilet (paper, pee and poo). These actions can reduce sewer overflows, traffic diversion, water pollution, and fish kills.

This outreach consists of many interviews in national and international media (including the Irish Times, RTÉ, Newstalk, BBC World Service, the Guardian, USA Today, and National Geographic) reaching a significant audience, likely in the tens of millions.

Having received positive feedback about his messages (and the funny way he presents the 3 Ps), Dr Curran volunteered to perform stand-up comedy about his research in Bright Club (a night of comedy by researchers), in Whelan’s, Dublin, in 2019. A recording of the event, “Dr Fatberg and the 3 Ps”, has had over 2,600 views on YouTube to date, the 6th most over 200 Bright Club Ireland videos.

Subsequently, industry partner Michael O’Dwyer invited Dr Curran to feature as one of the main characters, “Dr Fatberg”, in his company’s comic book “Attack of the Fatbergs”. He also appears in the 2021 sequel “Return of the Fatbergs!”. Both comics were illustrated by the US creator of the “Fatberg” character, Nathan T Wright, who has since worked with Dr Curran on two more multilingual UCD comics: “Finding Beo”, and the EPA-award winning “There’s Something About Ammonia”.

The outputs from our research collaboration with Tom on fats, oils and grease made a significant contribution to knowledge in a peer-reviewed journal paper. The subsequent dissemination of the key messages through humour in comics was very well received by industry.

— Michael O’Dwyer, CEO, SwiftComply

More recently, Dr Curran has promoted a proposed LEGO set about a fatberg, helping it receive the 10,000 public votes necessary to be reviewed for production by LEGO Group. If successful, it will further raise awareness of this largely hidden issue, contributing to the behaviour change needed to tackle fatbergs. Within the university, Dr Curran is also raising awareness with around 100 UCD students every year in the modules he teaches.


Economic and environmental impact

Although the economic impact of Dr Curran’s awareness-raising efforts has not been directly assessed, it is clear that preventing fatbergs has significant economic impact, saving countries millions in tackling blockages and dealing with flooding, property damage and environmental harm. Combined, Dr Curran’s research and outreach activities are reducing the potential environmental and health impacts of fatbergs.

Dr Curran’s research has shown that fatbergs have been reduced by about 95% in Dublin city since the FOG control programme was introduced in 2008, wherein commercial food service establishments are inspected to ensure they have appropriate grease traps installed and appropriate waste management procedures.


Political impact

In 2016, Dr Curran was invited to meetings of the UK’s FOGWise Steering Group, made of stakeholders from industry, academia and water utilities. Dr Curran gave feedback on the draft version of an upcoming publication from the group – “Foodservice – Fat, Oil and Grease Management Guide” – which gives people involved in FOG management roles knowledge about the importance of disposing of FOG responsibly, along with practical ways to do so.

The 2017 journal paper was recently mentioned more than a dozen times in an EU policy report exploring potential new sources of biofuel. The research is helping to pave the way for FOG to be repurposed as a source of energy.

Dr Curran met Philip Dunne MP (Chairman of UK Parliament Environmental Audit Committee) at the 2021 European FOG Summit. In his opening speech, Mr Dunne specifically remarked on the awareness-raising impact of Dr Curran's comic character “Dr Fatberg”.


Technological and academic impact

Food outlets and water utilities can work together to use grease trap equipment and sensors to prevent and detect blockages. Dr Curran previously collaborated with a world-renowned expert, Professor Joel Ducoste, to develop an advance warning system to detect sewer blockages using low-cost, internet-connected sensors.

The main journal paper arising from this work has had significant impact on the academic FOG community. With more than 100 citations it has a field-weighted citation impact of 2.55, meaning it has been cited by other researchers more than twice as much as similar articles. Dr Curran has also participated in several international conferences, as listed in the References section below. He was recently interviewed by the international authors of two books about fatbergs and sewers – "Gory Details: Adventures From the Dark Side of Science" and "Pipe dreams: The urgent global quest to transform the toilet".


Selected media and outreach


Selected conferences and events

  • Exhibited fatberg at National Ploughing Championships 2018, UCD Festival (2019, 2022)
  • Invitations to 3 European FOG Summits: 2021 in Brighton (moderator); 2019 in Amsterdam (panellist); 2018 in Amsterdam (speaker)
  • Invited keynote speaker on FOG, Cranfield University, Sept 2015
  • Invited speaker at III General Assembly Meeting European Waste to Advanced Biofuels Association, Brussels, June 2015
  • Invited speaker at Water Ireland Conference, Ashbourne, March 2015


Selected academic outputs

  • Curran, T. P., Broderick, C., & Ducoste, J. (2018). Preliminary tests of sensors to detect sewer network blockages. In 2018 ASABE Annual International Meeting, Detroit (p. 1). American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers. http://hdl.handle.net/10197/10379
  • Curran, T., O’Dwyer, M., Orr, B., Wright, N. (2019). Telling the story of sewer fatbergs using creative approaches Poster). SCI:COM 2019, Dublin. http://dx.doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.16150.91201 
  • Engelhaupt, E. (2021). Gory Details: Adventures From the Dark Side of Science. Washington, USA: National Geographic Society
  • Wald, C. (2022). Pipe dreams: The urgent global quest to transform the toilet. Avid Reader Press / Simon & Schuster
  • Wallace, Thomas; Gibbons, David; O'Dwyer, Michael; Curran, Thomas P. (2017). "International evolution of fat, oil and grease (FOG) waste management – A review". Journal of Environmental Management. 187: 424–435. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2016.11.003


Selected reviewing

  • Extern examiner at Cranfield University of PhD theses on FOG in 2017 and 2019
  • Invited reviewer of 2019 Hong Kong Government-funded research proposal on FOG management