IMPACT CASE STUDY
In Ireland in 2018, over 70% of prisoners in solitary confinement, and 8% of the general prison population, suffered severe and disabling mental illnesses, a phenomenon heavily criticised by the United Nations. Dr Cox’s research shows that these failings are long-standing. To influence public debate on the mental health crisis in Irish prisons, Dr Cox co-devised a series of events that informed a wide range of people of the enduring neglect of prisoners’ mental health.
Through her research – and these innovative, award-winning arts projects – Dr Cox communicated challenging materials and histories, influencing public perceptions of prisoners’ right to psychiatric services in appropriate settings. Ultimately, this has contributed to the wellbeing of prisoners and ex-offenders.
From 2014, Dr Cox led a multifaceted research project looking at mental illness in Irish prisons from 1830 to today. The research drew on neglected historic prison and medical records and is the first in-depth study of the topic. Modern prison regimes developed during the nineteenth century. These included the ‘separate system of confinement’, which required prisoners to be isolated in cells for around 18 hours each day. Dr Cox’s research showed that these prison regimes have had a detrimental impact on prisoners’ minds, producing or exacerbating psychiatric conditions.
Her research highlighted a strong resistance to change in penal policy, despite widespread official recognition that the separate system led to significant and lasting damage to prisoners. Elements of that system remain today in the use of solitary confinement, segregation and ‘restricted regimes’. High levels of mental illness among prisoners, and poor medical care, have been integral to penal reform campaigns since the 1830s. Prisoners, as well as NGOs, have agitated for improved conditions.
Through oral interviews – with current prison staff, prisoners and ex-offenders – conducted as part of arts-related events, Dr Cox’s project showed that these patterns persist in Irish prisons today, and that prisoners’ and ex-offenders’ wellbeing can be improved through working with historical materials in participatory arts projects.
This is the first time I have ever been heard, that I have ever spoken about my experience; I got to tell my story, from the age of 12 upwards from the time of reform school, borstal and time in prison.
— The Trial participant, 2018
With art sector and academic collaborators, Dr Cox coproduced and co-devised several innovative arts projects:
The plays and art installation were toured in Ireland and the UK. Each event drew on original historical research by Dr Cox, Dr Oisín Wall, Dr Fiachra Byrne and Professor Hilary Marland. The events examined the history of mental illness, addiction, self-harm and psychiatric treatment in adult and juvenile prisons from the nineteenth century to the present day.
The Examination and The Trial blended historical enquiry with contemporary research and directly involved imprisoned people who, through their participation in a series of creative workshops and oral interviews, were cocreators of the final productions.
To expand the reach and impact of each event, Dr Cox and her team organised a series of supporting activities. These included post-show panel discussions following performances of the plays and at the launch of The Trial. The team contributed to various print and radio media, maintained and published original research blogposts on the Prison Project website, and contributed to a range of arts sector and NGO publications.
Between 2016 and 2019, Dr Cox brought knowledge to new audiences, changing perspectives on crime, mental illness and criminal justice. Around 83,000 people attended the original performances of the events. Subsequent tours expanded these large audiences. 85% of respondents to audience surveys reported the events led them to reflect on unfamiliar social justice issues and think differently about prisons and prisoners’ mental health:
“Created awareness of lack of choice & control around a person’s physical and mental health while in prison.” “I … did not appreciate the mental anguish prisoners experience.”
— The Examination audience members (2019)
“What an amazing way to explore multiple voices and perspectives on a complex and nuanced topic. Innovative … Fascinating to see how historical and contemporary themes align and how historical perspective can inform contemporary policy on healthcare in Irish prison.”
— The Trial audience member (2018)
Co-produced by Dr Cox with Brokentalkers, the play The Examination won ‘Best Production’ at the 23rd Irish Times Theatre Awards (2020) and the Dublin Fringe Festival Awards (2019). Willie White, who suffered psychiatric illness in prison, also won ‘Best Actor’ at the Dublin Fringe.
Prisoners and ex-offenders experienced positive outcomes having interrogated research materials and participated in events led and co-devised by Dr Cox. And they said that history gave their experiences ‘more weight’ and helped them feel heard and believed:
"Helped me to release some of the anger I had within me about my prison experience.”
— The Trial participant (2018)
Between October 2015 and June 2017, Dr Cox co-convened two policy conferences. The first was held at the Shard, London (February 2016) and the second at the National Gallery of Ireland, Dublin (June 2017). These developed links with prison reform organisations in the UK and Ireland, including the Howard League for Penal Reform, Irish Penal Reform Trust, the Irish Prison Service, prison psychiatrists and medical staff, probation officers, and the authors of key reports on mental health in prison. Speakers at the conferences examined the work of penal reformers and the enduring nature of mental illness in prison, asking how history can inform current work on prison medicine.
Through Dr Cox’s collaborations, penal reform advocates recognised the importance of history and art for their work, praising the integrity and quality of Dr Cox’s projects:
“History is a way that we can benchmark progress. It tells us that positive change is fragile … It [the project] brought us face to face with society’s complicity in social inequalities, to profound effect. We couldn’t look away.”
— Fíona Ní Chinnéide, Irish Penal Reform Trust (2020)
Dr Cox and the team published original academic research articles. They contributed to podcasts and blog series and to the publications of her policy partners, like the Howard League for Penal Reform (see References below). She co-designed novel methodologies, blending historical research with contemporary experiences. This approach was integral to her works’ successes:
“Using interviews with prisoners and historical research, our prejudices and assumptions about prisons and prisoners are called out, switched up … the sum of those parts is an extraordinary thing, a piece of theatre unlike any other.”
— Review of The Examination, The Stage (2019)
“The presentation of historical cases alongside more recent ones encouraged reflection on changes and continuities in the health experiences of prisoners."
— The Trial, audience member (2018)
The topic “was handled with immense sensitivity, underpinned by in-depth high-quality research that was transformed into something powerful, meaningful and accessible through art.”
— Irish Penal Reform Trust (2020)
“A more politically sly and artfully provocative piece than you might expect for a show developed as part of an academic research project … Wisely, too, the show offers no easy escapes: both the health provisions of prisons and our own ideas of punishment and reform need careful and constant examination.”
— Peter Crawley, Irish Times, 5 March 2019
“As well as being an intrinsically rewarding theatrical experience in its own right, Disorder Contained performs an important social function. It attests to the synergies that are possible when historical inquiry avails of other cultural formats to reflect on social practices ... in the present ... it emphasises the inherent value of combining close historical research into behaviours with recreational and artistic forms to illuminate practices in the present that society is often reluctant to interrogate.”
— James Kelly, Professor of History, Dublin City University
"Living Inside provided “an unprecedented opportunity” to advance the remit of Kilmainham Gaol Museum by “linking historical and recent prisoner experience through the sustained, rigorous and sensitive scholarship delivered by Catherine Cox and her team”.
— Brian Crowley, Curator of Collections, Kilmainham Gaol Museum, Dublin
“It was a pleasure to see this show and it was very true to my experience and very well done. It’s top class and a credit to everyone involved.”
— John Lonergan, ex-Governor of Mountjoy Prison
“The History of Prison Health project played an extremely valuable role in humanising the men and women in prison and places of detention. It helped audiences see beyond the crimes committed and the demonization of certain groups of people, their families and their communities, to focus instead on our common humanity and frailty … This project reminded us that recent progressive reforms achieved in the penal system are reversible, and must be embedded in practice and policy to withstand environmental pressures like political change or recessions. From a penal reformer perspective, this project told us that we have work to do, but also that we are not alone!”
— Fíona Ní Chinnéide, Executive Director, Irish Penal Reform Trust
“There was something … groundbreaking in all of this.”
“The historical case studies became a really important anchor to the workshops in more ways than I had anticipated … Working on The Trial has had significant impact on my professional development and profile as an artist.”
— Sinead McCann
“The power of the production, the writing, and what it had to say sociologically was, in my opinion, something truly rare, worthwhile and ... eye-opening … the work that had gone into The Examination by Catherine Cox was evident from the start and without it the production wouldn’t have had the impact it had…”
— Rick O’Shea, Judge, 2019 Dublin Fringe Festival, Broadcaster, RTÉ
Project website (research blogs and discussion of arts projects)
Catherine Cox, University College Dublin and Hilary Marland, University of Warwick, ‘‘Their minds gave way’: mental disorder and nineteenth-century prison discipline’, ECAN Bulletin, 44 (June 2020)
Fiachra Byrne, University College Dublin, ‘‘In humanity’s machine’: prison health and history’, ECAN Bulletin, 33 (July 2017)
History in Action podcast: interview with Professor Matt Smith, University of Strathclyde
Catherine Cox and Hilary Marland, ‘The Great Disgrace to our Age’: Desperate women, crime, drink and mental disorder in Liverpool Borough Prison’, Social History Blog (June 2019)
Rachel Bennett, Catherine Cox and Hilary Marland ‘Disturbed minds and disruptive bodies’, Wellcome Collection (August 2018)
Catherine Cox and Hilary Marland, ‘Alias Grace: how Irish migration and the female criminal mind were viewed in the Victorian era’, Conversation (July 2018)
‘The Trial Case Study’, Arts and Health, Centre for Arts & Health, University Hospital Waterford
‘The Trial: Screams that could be heard all over the prison’, Deirdre Falvey, Irish Times, 15 April 2018
Catherine Cox and Hilary Marland, ‘“He must die or go mad in this place”: Prisoners, Insanity and the Pentonville Model Prison Experiment, 1842-1852’, Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 92 (2018), 78-109. doi.org/10.1353/bhm.2018.0004
Catherine Cox and Hilary Marland, ‘Broken Minds and Beaten Bodies: Cultures of Harm and the Management of Mental Illness in Late Nineteenth Century English and Irish Prisons’, Social History of Medicine, 31 (2018), 688-710. doi.org/10.1093/ shm/hky038
Catherine Cox and Hilary Marland, ‘“We are Recreating Bedlam”: A History of Mental Illness and Prison Systems in England and Ireland’, in Kathleen Kendell and Alice Mills (eds), Mental Health in Prisons: Critical Perspectives on Treatment and Confinement (Houndsmills: Palgrave, 2018), 25-47. doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-94090-8_2
Catherine Cox and Hilary Marland, ‘“Unfit for Reform or Punishment”: Liverpool Borough Gaol, Mental Disorder and Late Nineteenth-Century Prison Discipline’, Social History, 44 (2019), 173-210. doi.org/10.1080/03071022.2019.1579977
Oisín Wall, ‘‘Embarrassing the State’: The ‘Ordinary’ Prisoner Rights Movement in Ireland, 1972–6’, Journal of Contemporary History, 55:2 (2020), 388-410. doi.org/10.1177/0022009419863846